D&D is a set of rules. While these rules do have their implications which can be debated, people (and publishers) can and do twist and contort everything about D&D to where it can't possibly have any definition besides its most fundamental rules. Yet the line where something becomes "not D&D" is quite debatable (see the 3.x and 4e edition wars, with many stating that it's still D&D to them), but obviously there is a quite definite line or else every RPG is D&D.
(A prime reason I think my Olden Domain game fizzled after 6 or 7 sessions was that I was trying to be older-school-than-thou and monkeying around with the rules and procedures instead of just picking a D&D version and running it as-is. It did cap off with a "cleared the gnoll problem for the primitive villagers" resolution so that was good at least. And I've submitted that "gnoll" tower to the One Page Dungeon contest.)
The quote mentioned here is completely pointless. "Warhammer isn't like D&D..." because it's got a different character creation and combat and magic system. When I first came into contact with Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay in the very early 90s, I took that atmosphere and decided that's how I'm going to run D&D from now on. My monsters don't all have treasure, and my games aren't "about" glory and riches unless the PCs decide that's what it's about, and even then I won't serve it up on a silver platter.
Not to mention the published WFRP campaigns (at least for the first edition) don't match the atmosphere Mr. Wallis describes. You don't end the Enemy Within campaign (the very campaign which spawned Mr. Wallis' quote) covered in shit. Or Doomstones, either. Warhammer's style and atmosphere can be transferred quite easily to D&D, and only D&D's high level play might have trouble making the jump back.
The post here, linked as support to the post above, seems to name Tolkien as the prime inspiration to Warhammer, but I've always thought of it as quite Moorcockian. Either way, to some degree both had some influence on D&D (both important but neither prime influences), and I don't see how the American spirit defines D&D. Sure, there are expectations and general perceptions about the games, but both games can be quite played exactly like the other. Doomstones was originally written for D&D, as I recall. That Dungeonland and Beyond the Magic Mirror were directly ripped from Lewis Carroll probably gives it the British flavor, but I think this little bit from Castle Greyhawk would have fit wonderfully as a Warhammer adventure.
Then there's this thread (remember Wick's anti-D&Disms leading up to this game's release?) and resulting discussion. "Let me put it this way to start with: why does Cthulhu automatically eat 1d3 adventurers per round?" is supposed to be evidence that Call of Cthulhu is the anti-D&D. A defender states, "That Lovecraft fiction is as far from D&D as one can conceive..." which has to be objectively wrong just based on Appendix N.
Even Matt Finch draws a line between the atmospheres of Call of Cthulhu and D&D in the comments here.
When it comes to D&D, my line is somewhere around where Mr. Mornard calls it: "A hit chart, a saving throw table, some character progression, monsters, treasure, and some rules on air combat, sea combat, and building a barony. Add imagination and go apeshit." (he forgot character classes, but maybe that's under character progression) You can take the basics and make sci-fi, Victorian, ancient mythic Greece, hardcore historical, horror, comedy, action-adventure, romance, hard-boiled detective, or anything you want and it's still D&D as long as it retains the core elements.
But this sort of thing is why I was fretting yesterday. Death Frost Doom is nearly complete, and I'm worried a bit because I'm certain it (and my other forthcoming work) will be accused of not "feeling" like D&D (no matter what rules I officially release it under, I have a feeling it'll be bought and used most by D&D players, I think it's safe and factual to say!) by some even if I attempt to make it note-perfect on the rules.
(A prime reason I think my Olden Domain game fizzled after 6 or 7 sessions was that I was trying to be older-school-than-thou and monkeying around with the rules and procedures instead of just picking a D&D version and running it as-is. It did cap off with a "cleared the gnoll problem for the primitive villagers" resolution so that was good at least. And I've submitted that "gnoll" tower to the One Page Dungeon contest.)
The quote mentioned here is completely pointless. "Warhammer isn't like D&D..." because it's got a different character creation and combat and magic system. When I first came into contact with Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay in the very early 90s, I took that atmosphere and decided that's how I'm going to run D&D from now on. My monsters don't all have treasure, and my games aren't "about" glory and riches unless the PCs decide that's what it's about, and even then I won't serve it up on a silver platter.
Not to mention the published WFRP campaigns (at least for the first edition) don't match the atmosphere Mr. Wallis describes. You don't end the Enemy Within campaign (the very campaign which spawned Mr. Wallis' quote) covered in shit. Or Doomstones, either. Warhammer's style and atmosphere can be transferred quite easily to D&D, and only D&D's high level play might have trouble making the jump back.
The post here, linked as support to the post above, seems to name Tolkien as the prime inspiration to Warhammer, but I've always thought of it as quite Moorcockian. Either way, to some degree both had some influence on D&D (both important but neither prime influences), and I don't see how the American spirit defines D&D. Sure, there are expectations and general perceptions about the games, but both games can be quite played exactly like the other. Doomstones was originally written for D&D, as I recall. That Dungeonland and Beyond the Magic Mirror were directly ripped from Lewis Carroll probably gives it the British flavor, but I think this little bit from Castle Greyhawk would have fit wonderfully as a Warhammer adventure.
Then there's this thread (remember Wick's anti-D&Disms leading up to this game's release?) and resulting discussion. "Let me put it this way to start with: why does Cthulhu automatically eat 1d3 adventurers per round?" is supposed to be evidence that Call of Cthulhu is the anti-D&D. A defender states, "That Lovecraft fiction is as far from D&D as one can conceive..." which has to be objectively wrong just based on Appendix N.
Even Matt Finch draws a line between the atmospheres of Call of Cthulhu and D&D in the comments here.
When it comes to D&D, my line is somewhere around where Mr. Mornard calls it: "A hit chart, a saving throw table, some character progression, monsters, treasure, and some rules on air combat, sea combat, and building a barony. Add imagination and go apeshit." (he forgot character classes, but maybe that's under character progression) You can take the basics and make sci-fi, Victorian, ancient mythic Greece, hardcore historical, horror, comedy, action-adventure, romance, hard-boiled detective, or anything you want and it's still D&D as long as it retains the core elements.
But this sort of thing is why I was fretting yesterday. Death Frost Doom is nearly complete, and I'm worried a bit because I'm certain it (and my other forthcoming work) will be accused of not "feeling" like D&D (no matter what rules I officially release it under, I have a feeling it'll be bought and used most by D&D players, I think it's safe and factual to say!) by some even if I attempt to make it note-perfect on the rules.

