Tuesday, May 5, 2009

D&D Has a Lot of Baggage

D&D is a set of rules. While these rules do have their implications which can be debated, people (and publishers) can and do twist and contort everything about D&D to where it can't possibly have any definition besides its most fundamental rules. Yet the line where something becomes "not D&D" is quite debatable (see the 3.x and 4e edition wars, with many stating that it's still D&D to them), but obviously there is a quite definite line or else every RPG is D&D.

(A prime reason I think my Olden Domain game fizzled after 6 or 7 sessions was that I was trying to be older-school-than-thou and monkeying around with the rules and procedures instead of just picking a D&D version and running it as-is. It did cap off with a "cleared the gnoll problem for the primitive villagers" resolution so that was good at least. And I've submitted that "gnoll" tower to the One Page Dungeon contest.)

The quote mentioned here is completely pointless. "Warhammer isn't like D&D..." because it's got a different character creation and combat and magic system. When I first came into contact with Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay in the very early 90s, I took that atmosphere and decided that's how I'm going to run D&D from now on. My monsters don't all have treasure, and my games aren't "about" glory and riches unless the PCs decide that's what it's about, and even then I won't serve it up on a silver platter.

Not to mention the published WFRP campaigns (at least for the first edition) don't match the atmosphere Mr. Wallis describes. You don't end the Enemy Within campaign (the very campaign which spawned Mr. Wallis' quote) covered in shit. Or Doomstones, either. Warhammer's style and atmosphere can be transferred quite easily to D&D, and only D&D's high level play might have trouble making the jump back.

The post here, linked as support to the post above, seems to name Tolkien as the prime inspiration to Warhammer, but I've always thought of it as quite Moorcockian. Either way, to some degree both had some influence on D&D (both important but neither prime influences), and I don't see how the American spirit defines D&D. Sure, there are expectations and general perceptions about the games, but both games can be quite played exactly like the other. Doomstones was originally written for D&D, as I recall. That Dungeonland and Beyond the Magic Mirror were directly ripped from Lewis Carroll probably gives it the British flavor, but I think this little bit from Castle Greyhawk would have fit wonderfully as a Warhammer adventure.

Then there's this thread (remember Wick's anti-D&Disms leading up to this game's release?) and resulting discussion. "Let me put it this way to start with: why does Cthulhu automatically eat 1d3 adventurers per round?" is supposed to be evidence that Call of Cthulhu is the anti-D&D. A defender states, "That Lovecraft fiction is as far from D&D as one can conceive..." which has to be objectively wrong just based on Appendix N.

Even Matt Finch draws a line between the atmospheres of Call of Cthulhu and D&D in the comments here.

When it comes to D&D, my line is somewhere around where Mr. Mornard calls it: "A hit chart, a saving throw table, some character progression, monsters, treasure, and some rules on air combat, sea combat, and building a barony. Add imagination and go apeshit." (he forgot character classes, but maybe that's under character progression) You can take the basics and make sci-fi, Victorian, ancient mythic Greece, hardcore historical, horror, comedy, action-adventure, romance, hard-boiled detective, or anything you want and it's still D&D as long as it retains the core elements.

But this sort of thing is why I was fretting yesterday. Death Frost Doom is nearly complete, and I'm worried a bit because I'm certain it (and my other forthcoming work) will be accused of not "feeling" like D&D (no matter what rules I officially release it under, I have a feeling it'll be bought and used most by D&D players, I think it's safe and factual to say!) by some even if I attempt to make it note-perfect on the rules.

Monday, May 4, 2009

Don't Fall In

"The pit is not literally bottomless, but a mortal man will die of old age before hitting the bottom. A young elf might live long enough to die upon impact."

(just thrown up/VOMITED here because Twitter's message restrictions are too restrictive for these random preview quotes!)

Meet Addison Lakely, Herbalist and Good Citizen of Pembrooktonshire

Addison Lakely is a centenarian who still enjoys surprisingly good health. Long ago he was known as a master gardener and herbalist, but for the past thirty years he has been living off of his savings and the goodwill of the townsfolk. He is a well-known personality about town, being its oldest resident and taking frequent long walks around town, conversing with the people and playing with the children.

However, his mental state has been deteriorating for some time, and his short-term memory is almost non-existent. When he greets neighbors, he often forgets that he has met them before, even if he has greeted them every day for the previous month. This, combined with his frequent mumbling to himself, has caused many people to avoid him. He has perfect memory of things several decades old, however, and does tell such tales that entertain the people... the first time or three he tells them.

Addison is very concerned about the happiness and well-being of his neighbors, and so takes care to maintain the cheery, folksy appeal of Pembrooktonshire life. To accomplish this, he uses a talent he cultivated long ago: Lakely is a magic-user of some small ability. Eighty years ago he apprenticed under a great magician, and although he had great aptitude for the magical arts, social pressures convinced him to give it up. He did manage to attain fifth level, but these days has but three spells in his book: Read Magic, Detect Magic, and Dispel Magical Aura. Due to age and other factors, aside from his spell usage he is for all statistical purposes a normal man.

Addison's long walks are often just an excuse for him to detect magic around town, so that he may then follow it up with Dispel Magic Aura. This third level spell removes the magical signature from an item/area/person, but not the magic; it functions as normal but no longer detects as magical. The spell is permanent (until dispelled by magic!), but anyone detecting magic while using a scrying spell can see the obscured enchantment.

However, in his senile state, Addison thinks he's dispelling the magic altogether. So for over twenty years now, every magical thing in Pembrooktonshire has existed in secret, and nobody knows...

Learn more about Pembrooktonshire in the adventure module No Dignity in Death: The Three Brides, coming soon from LotFP.

Sunday, May 3, 2009

I Play, the Older School Than Thou Edition!

I haven't done one of these for awhile... but for today's game we dug down into the deepest depths of oldschool lore and came back with...


RATS ON A STICK.

Complete with raisin noses and pumpkin seed ears. And soy bodies for the non-meat eaters in my group.

Bask in my awesomeness. But not for too long, else I'll have to charge you for it.


... served with a side dish of skewered chocolate-bathed pears, carrots, tea, coffee, and various other snackies.

"Why do I bother eating before I come here?" is a lament not unheard in these parts.

Updates and Notes

I'm up to 28 copies of Green Devil Face #1 and 34 copies of Green Devil Face #2 sold, which is actually more than I had anticipated this quickly, so thanks for that! Thanks as well for the kind comments I've received. Make sure you also let the individual contributors know how you feel about their work!

No Dignity in Death: The Three Brides was a project submitted to a publisher that just got the "we're not a good match at this time" response on Thursday, and I started the "marketing" for that on Friday. Might as well do it myself, right? It's all written and just needs maps and art... and perhaps a bit of organizational editing. Laura seems keen on tackling that art after she finishes up the Death Frost Doom work. To keep costs down the art won't be as extensive as I'd hoped to get the publisher to commission (and Laura's agreed to do this latest slew of artwork for a steal of a price - partially because she's drawing on A4 paper for these instead of A3), but if you guys don't find the remaining graphic ideas interesting I'll eat my hat.

So the plan will be Death Frost Doom first, No Dignity in Death second, and Insect Shrine (which I unfortunately have a lot of money promised to people before publication, not to mention the size of the module which means no in-house printing... lots of mistakes beyond the obvious were made there) as soon as funds allow. Unfortunately I don't have any other income at the moment, which should ensure these projects get done in a timely manner but they have to be self-sufficient. Insect Shrine pre-order people won't be able to get the other items free this time, but they will get it for just shipping + Paypal fees, which will be significantly cheaper than what everyone else will be charged.

The other module (St. McIver) I'd talked about is still just in original game notes form with no art or anything commissioned so it's just a future idea, and at some point the Asylum adventure will be moved up to "go" status as well. In the meantime, every Monday, Wednesday and Friday will see a No Dignity in Death promo until it is released, and if everything else works out (this is still just a hopeful thing since I won't even send the art specs for it until all the Death Frost Doom art is in... one thing at a time!) there will be a companion volume of purely optional resources for the No Dignity adventure released simultaneously.

I have managed to secure the money for the laser printer I wanted (selling a ton of stuff to afford it, noooo... duplex printing, yes...!), and I'm currently researching where I should buy the thing from. I decided to put money into the printer instead of towards Insect Shrine debts for one simple reason: The money isn't enought to clear Insect Shrine so the project would still be stuck anyway, and generating anything more would be iffy (I'm already at the point where a Green Devil Face order means a ton of swearing and illwill towards my current printer, and tomorrow evening's work of printing 7 booklets out to mail on Monday will be an epic battle!).

As projects near completion, I'm looking for advice on how to approach vendors. I believe my efforts and the traditional movement as a whole can only benefit by making stuff available from as many places as possible. I have this goofy dream that if enough of us "basement publishers" can get the word out and demonstrate the ability to move some units, larger companies will see that there is money here and I think there are reputable companies that could make some respectable and uncompromising Early Edition material, which in turn will mean more gamers disconnected from "the scene" being exposed to, and in some cases converted to, "our ways."

Once Death Frost Doom is out, I will also work to get set up with pdf vendors as well, and from then on the plan will be to release pdfs one week after print releases are available, so that people ordering pdf copies don't get to read their stuff before first-day print orderers have a chance to.

Due to the printer issues and the expanded time it causes Green Devil Face to take, and now also No Dignity in Death landing back in my lap, I haven't really taken the time to look at the suggested options for the online game I'd talked about, but I am pleased that people seem interested. I'm off to Rome at the end of this week (not on my dime so don't hold it against me as I talk about money issues), so I'll look into online game tables (my original "what I want" post seemed to forget that unless everyone does mapping, players can't share the map!) when I return.

So that's the plan. Any questions, concerns, or most importantly things I should rethink, do let me know.

Friday, May 1, 2009

Meet Royston Haddingfield, Builder and Good Citizen of Pembrooktonshire

Haddingfield is a smart and still-strong middle-aged widower, who along with his sons Tony, Reggie, and Vasey, perform most of the major construction and renovation work around town. There are few residences, and fewer public buildings, that have not been improved by the work of the Haddingfields' skillful hands.

In his spare time he socializes and plays darts down at The Last Stop, and is an accomplished whittler. Every Saturday morning he dutifully takes a beautiful bouquet of flowers to the grave of his wife. He has never so much as thought about another woman in the six years since she passed.

Haddingfield and his sons scam the town in one particular way: They always screw up their jobs in minor, but noteworthy ways. They then offer to fix it for free, and are willing to construct a secret cellar in return for the client not speaking about the mistake and thus ruining the Haddingfield's perfect reputation. They've been running this scheme for two generations now, and so most of the people of Pembrooktonshire have a secret place of their own that no one knows about, and they also think nobody else has such a place.

Learn more about Pembrooktonshire in the adventure module No Dignity in Death: The Three Brides, coming soon from LotFP.

Thursday, April 30, 2009

Questions From Me, The Publisher, To You, The Potential Customer

The next month or three will be very busy, as I hope to have no less than four adventure modules out during that time. Two at the very least.

But I need some input. I don't know which game I should use to release these things, or whether I should use one at all. And for these things to be successful, they need to be convenient to use for you.

(Insect Shrine will be OSRIC since that's what I advertised all that time ago.)

So tell me...

Would you be more likely to buy a module that was "branded" and statted for one of the specific clones (Swords & Wizardry, Labyrinth Lord, OSRIC, etc)?

Would you be less likely to buy a module that was specifically branded for a clone you're not using?

Would you be less likely to purchase an adventure that was not specifically for any of the clones, with general statting (for example: "In this room are six zombies," with no additional stats or notes, with unique or unusual creatures being listed along the lines of, "... armor class equal to chain plus shield...") that you would need to "convert" no matter which version you're playing?

(one thing I will not do is dual/triple/whatever stat blocks for the different games as it takes too much space and looks very unattractive on the page...)

What other thoughts and concerns do you, the buying public, have along these lines that I should be aware of?

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

"There are a lot of really crazy people in this hobby."

That's a James Maliszewski quote.

The comments to his post here also indicate that there are a lot of fruitcakes in this hobby.

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Green Devil Face: Reviewed!

Here! Thanks Melan!

Green Devil Face Orders Update

All orders received since the last update went to the post office this morning.

The total sold is now 22 for #1 and 25 for #2.

Copies have already been received in North America as of yesterday, so if you were one of the first-day orderers, be on the lookout!